Refocus and redirect
Jan. 5th, 2011 09:38 pmMy post on scheduling seems to have attracted attention mostly for the scheduled to the breaking point middle class versus abandoned lower class, which is a topic worthy of investigation, but not what I was going for. Luckily, I've thought of a better anecdote to illustrate it.
My mom signed me up for swim classes when I was fairly young- 6, maybe? Our immediate neighborhood (say, four blocks worth) was middle class but the surrounding area was not, and the YMCA drew heavily from the poor/wc group. The first day of swim class, I had the following conversation with my instructor.
instructor (angry): YOU DID THAT WRONG. DO IT THIS WAY.
me: okay.
instructor (even angrier): DO NOT TALK BACK TO ME.
I don't even think I complained, my mom saw it and switched me to a different class. But from the fact that that guy was employed, I assume someone was letting him teach their kids. By moving me solely because the the instructor was mean to me, my mom taught me that my feelings are important and needed to be respected, even by adults, things I generally think are good, although g-d knows some parents go overboard with it. Obviously this isn't the only way to teach kids that lesson, but it's part of a larger package where middle class kids grow up in a world where their words are magic and poor kids don't.
My mom signed me up for swim classes when I was fairly young- 6, maybe? Our immediate neighborhood (say, four blocks worth) was middle class but the surrounding area was not, and the YMCA drew heavily from the poor/wc group. The first day of swim class, I had the following conversation with my instructor.
instructor (angry): YOU DID THAT WRONG. DO IT THIS WAY.
me: okay.
instructor (even angrier): DO NOT TALK BACK TO ME.
I don't even think I complained, my mom saw it and switched me to a different class. But from the fact that that guy was employed, I assume someone was letting him teach their kids. By moving me solely because the the instructor was mean to me, my mom taught me that my feelings are important and needed to be respected, even by adults, things I generally think are good, although g-d knows some parents go overboard with it. Obviously this isn't the only way to teach kids that lesson, but it's part of a larger package where middle class kids grow up in a world where their words are magic and poor kids don't.